Member Portal
Join Our Co-op

In this blog post, we’ll delve into the world of Homeowners Associations (HOAs) and explore the evolving legal power they possess in our contemporary world. HOAs have long been a topic of interest, with their influence extending into various aspects of residential communities. In this reading, we will examine the factual landscape surrounding the legal authority of HOAs and determine whether it has increased or decreased in recent years. 

Historical Perspective

In the past, HOAs possessed considerable legal power, allowing them to enforce rules and regulations, collect fees, and impose fines on homeowners who violated these guidelines. The legal framework surrounding HOAs was primarily governed by state laws and court decisions, which varied from jurisdiction to jurisdiction. As a result, the extent of HOA authority could differ significantly depending on the location. 

Recent Legal Trends

Over the years, the legal landscape surrounding HOAs has undergone some changes. While HOAs still retain certain powers, there has been a growing emphasis on homeowner rights and protection. Several factors have contributed to this shift: 

  1. Legislative Reforms: Some states have enacted legislation to regulate HOAs more closely, aiming to strike a balance between the authority of HOAs and the rights of homeowners. These reforms often introduce stricter guidelines regarding fee collection, dispute resolution, and transparency.
  1. Court Decisions: Courts have occasionally scrutinized HOA actions and rulings, ensuring they adhere to the principles of fairness and reasonableness. This increased judicial oversight has provided homeowners with greater protection against potential abuses of power by HOAs.
  1. Homeowner Empowerment: Recognizing the need for homeowner representation, some jurisdictions have bolstered the rights of residents within HOAs. This includes granting homeowners the ability to participate in decision-making processes, attend board meetings, and run for positions on the HOA board.
  1. Changing Social Attitudes: Society’s perception of HOAs has evolved over time, with increased scrutiny on their actions. Homeowners are more informed and assertive about their rights, prompting HOAs to adopt more transparent and inclusive practices.


Final Words 

In today’s world, the legal power of HOAs has experienced a nuanced transformation. While HOAs still retain certain authority, there has been a shift towards greater homeowner rights and legal protections. Legislative reforms, court decisions, homeowner empowerment, and changing social attitudes have contributed to this evolution. It is important for both homeowners and HOAs to be aware of these changes and understand their respective rights and responsibilities. Ultimately, striking a balance between community governance and individual freedoms remains a key objective in the realm of HOAs. 

If you’d like to learn more about how Innovia helps independent management companies enhance their value to the communities they serve, schedule a membership discovery call.